Over the last decade, the protection of owl roosting locations has diminished in Manhattan. Social media influencers have promoted the idea that the public and bird watchers have the right to see any owl that comes into New York County and their locations should always be disclosed. This simply isn’t true. Wildlife doesn’t exist to entertain us.
Sadly, there are a many inexperienced birders and unethical photographers who will exploit and harass any owl that comes into Manhattan, so broadcasting an owl’s location is harmful to the bird. A widespread broadcast of a location, or sometimes even just a few photographs published on social media can cause large disruptive crowds to gather around an owl. And no mater how well behaved a group of owl watchers is, having 25 or more individuals under a roosting bird is certainly going to cause the animal some stress.
Through a series of owls, starting with a Saw-whet Owl roosting in a Holly Tree for a winter, the Central Park Snowy Owl, and through a number of “named” owls, Barry, Gerald(ine), Flaco, Bramble, and now an American Barn Owls family, social media influencers and photographers have turn owls into celebrities, ripe for exploitation and the public now sees them as a source of entertainment. Worse yet, these influencers have enlisted the public’s help in finding owls, whose locations they then report widely. Especially after the campaign to promote Flaco as a “free and happy bird”, average New Yorker’s now think freely sharing and reporting an owl’s location is the right thing to do.
Owls deserve their privacy while sleeping. Ethics guidelines from both local and national birding organizations, recommend not posting any owl’s location online. Unfortunately, most social media influencers describe this as “gatekeeping”. It is not. This is simply a rationalization to excuse the exploitation of owls.
Owl locations aren’t something to be kept secret, however. The locations can be shared with anyone you know will watch the bird responsibly. The reasoning behind not posting owl locations online is that once you find an owl or know of an owl’s location, you are responsible for the behavior of anyone you share the location with. You simply can’t do this when you broadcast the owl’s location. This nuance is lost on the social media influencers and many photographers, who are more concerned more about self-promotion than their impact on an owl.
Reversing years of individuals exploiting owls by normalizing and promoting owl roosting locations won’t be solved overnight. It might take years to return to ethical birding standards in Manhattan. But we need to start the process.
A good place to start would be correcting how local birders use eBird. Social media influencers and photographers mine eBird data to look for owls. A single eBird report of a Snowy Owl will generate a feeding frenzy, and send dozens of photographers looking for the owl.
Recently, many birders are reporting very specific owl locations in their eBird reports. Most do so because they don’t realize the impact of making such reports. Others believe that since the news is already out on social media, they don’t need to bother with hiding owl locations in their eBird reports. This seems fine, but it sets a bad example for other birders. (I’ve been guilty of this sin.)
The bird watching community is a generous group of individuals, and they freely share information about sightings with each other. New birders seeing how generous everyone is about sharing information about sightings, often think it is fine to share owl location information. We are all so used to being helpful, we sometimes forget the process of how to bird ethically and be mindful of sensitive species.
When reporting owls on eBird, users have a few choices. Many birders choose to leave them off any checklist altogether or wait until it is confirmed that the owl has left the area before adding the owl to their checklists.
Another option is waiting a week or more and then add the owl using a more general location, such as an entire park or the New York County location, rather than a localized hotspot. (This keeps the owl sighting off the New York County Rare Bird Alert many influencers and photographers keep tabs on. But this is problematic, as it still lets people know there was an owl to inquire about.)
(While Long-eared Owls and American Barn Owls are hidden automatically on eBird, eBird does not filter out any associated photographs from its Recent Photographs listings, so including any photos of these species will telegraph the presence of an owl. Waiting a week or so to post photographs, will avoid this issue.)
When we do report an owl, since it is rare bird, eBird will require us to write a description of what we saw. Most birders use this field incorrectly. It was not intended to be used to enter the location information of the bird. Recently, while a Barred Owl was being reported widely the comments were:
- North of the Ramble
- In the ramble right next to a barn ow
- Very close to the Barn Owl. Large, barred. Was preening before flying off from its high branch to the top of a dead tree much closer to the ground. Large crowd watching it.
- Bramble
- Hunting around dusk
- Seen by many others
- Lifer! Seen with a huge group of birders. I believe this is the continuing bird nicknamed “Bramble” in the Ramble. Perched on a tree seen from trail south of maintenance meadow.
- Near Tupelo
- Continuing
None of these are the correct response. This is not what the comment line was designed for. The line is for the observer to describe the physical aspects of the bird that confirm the species, so an eBird reviewer can confirm the sighting. For a Barred Owl, that answer would be something like “Medium-sized owl, with dark brown eyes and brown and white striped plumage.” (I sometimes struggle with writing these descriptions. But having to describe what makes a bird the species it is, and not some similar species, is helping me become a better birder.)
Birders often also share specific location information about non-sensitive species in this comment line to aid other birders in locating the bird. However, this should be avoided with sensitive species such as owls or many nest locations. Ethical naturalists always remember to think first about the impact on the animal, before reporting a location, be it an owl, mammal like a coyote, nest or den.
So, please be careful about how you report owls on eBird. And when you see them being reported improperly, if you know the person who made the report, don’t shy away from having a discussion with them.
Bird’s needs over people’s. Birds first!